특허법인 남아이피그룹

Practice Notes Trademark Cancellation Actions in Korea

Introduction: Role of Cancellation Actions

Korea is a first-to-file jurisdiction where obtaining registered trademark rights is key to brand protection. Though applications are substantively examined for both absolute and relative refusal grounds, the Korean Ministry of Intellectual Property (MOIP, formerly KIPO) does not require applicants to furnish any evidence of actual use to obtain trademark rights or maintain a trademark registration through renewal. Once registered, a trademark can thus remain on the register indefinitely provided the owner attends to its renewal every 10 years and pays the necessary fees. 
 
On the positive side, this makes the acquisition and maintenance of trademark rights relatively simple and eliminates costs associated with preparing evidence of use, but on the other hand it can lead to a situation where a mark that is not being used — and in fact may never have been used — can block an application filed by another brand owner that intends to use an identical or similar mark in Korea. In this situation, a straightforward mechanism to allow for the clearing of “deadwood” via the cancellation of unused marks is essential.
 
Though actions based on non-use are the most common type of cancellation, and will be the primary focus of this article, it is also possible to cancel a registered trademark based on misleading or unfair use. Typical situations where these grounds may be invoked are, for example, if a trademark owner or licensee uses a modified version of their registered trademark to resemble another party’s trademark, causing consumer confusion, or if a trademark owner who has either provided or been granted a letter of consent uses their mark in an unfairly competitive manner resulting in consumer confusion.
 
For clarification, this article deals only with cancellation actions, which are based on conduct or circumstances that occur after a mark is registered, in contrast to invalidation actions that attack a defect that existed at the time the mark was registered, such as non-distinctiveness, conflict with a senior mark, bad-faith filing etc.
 
The grounds for cancelling a registered trademark may be broadly similar across many jurisdictions, but there are some factors specific to Korea that we hope to highlight below.

Grounds for Cancellation

The cancellation grounds most relevant to ordinary commercial trademarks are non-use and misleading use. Following a 2024 revision to the Trademark Act allowing for letters of consent, unfair competitive use by either party to a consent agreement was added as a new ground of cancellation.
 
  Non-use Misleading use Unfair competitive use (after letter of consent)
Statutory basis in Trademark Act Article 119(1)(3)  Article 119(1)(1) and (2) Article 119(1)(5-2)
Core ground No qualifying use in Korea for a continuous period of at least three years before filing, without justifiable reason. Use of the registered mark, or a similar mark, on relevant goods in a way that misleads consumers about quality or causes confusion with another business. Either party to a consent arrangement uses its registered mark for an unfair competitive purpose, misleading consumers about quality or causing confusion with another business.
Standing  No standing or interested party requirement: may be filed by any person (“straw man” filings are possible)
Principal proof issue Petitioner is not required to provide evidence of non-use: the trademark owner must establish qualifying use or a justifiable reason for non-use.

Petitioner must establish the acts constituting misleading use.

(Where misuse was by a licensee, the owner may have a defense if it exercised due care in supervising the licensee)    

Petitioner must establish the acts constituting unfair competitive use.
 
Effective date Cancellation takes effect retroactively from the filing date of the trial. Cancellation takes effect when the cancellation decision becomes final.

 

Bar to Re-filing

Once a cancellation petition has been filed, the trademark owner and certain users of the challenged mark are generally prevented from registering an identical or similar mark for identical or similar goods or services. This restriction runs from the filing date of the cancellation petition until three years after the cancellation becomes final (or, if the registration is surrendered or allowed to expire after the petition is filed, three years after that event). 
 
This is particularly meaningful in the context of non-use actions. Without this bar, a trademark owner facing cancellation of their mark due to non-use could simply ignore the action and re-file a new application for the same mark. However, assuming the cancellation action succeeds, in practice such a new application would be ineligible for registration.
 

Procedure & Statistics

Cancellation actions are heard in the first instance by the Intellectual Property Trial & Appeal Board (IPTAB), an administrative tribunal within MOIP. Cases are normally conducted via written submissions but oral hearings may be held where appropriate.
 
A typical first-instance cancellation proceeding takes around 9-12 months to conclude, with timing depending on participation of the parties, the evidence and complexity of the case. In a non-use cancellation action, because the owner bears the burden of proving qualifying use or a justifiable reason for non-use, cancellation may be expected if the owner does not respond with supporting evidence. 
 
IPTAB decisions can be appealed by either party to the IP High Court and ultimately to the Supreme Court on points of law.
 
MOIP statistics for January 2023 – July 2026 record 7,631 trademark cancellation cases that were decided on the merits (i.e. excluding cases dismissed on procedural grounds or withdrawn). Of these, cancellation was granted in 7,057 cases and rejected in 574 cases, resulting in an average cancellation grant rate of 92% for cases that reach a conclusion on the merits.
 
These numbers include all cancellation grounds, of which non-use actions make up the majority. While a success rate of over 90% is certainly high, it should be understood in context: most parties will conduct at least some research into the use of the mark and proceed with a cancellation action only if they are relatively confident of victory — where a mark is obviously being used for the relevant goods, a cancellation action would generally not be considered from the outset.
 

Non-use Cancellation: What You Need to Know

Background: Similarity Codes

Korea uses a system of “similarity codes” (also known as “similar group codes”) to classify goods and services. These codes are distinct from international trademark classes and are principally based on the old local classification that was used before Korea adopted the Nice classification in 1998. 
 
MOIP assigns similarity codes to all goods and services covered by a trademark application. Where marks are identical or similar, goods or services sharing the same similarity code will generally be treated as similar during examination. However, similarity codes are not conclusive, and the ultimate assessment depends on the nature, purpose, consumers and distribution channels of the relevant goods or services.
 
Understanding this system is important when seeking cancellation of a senior trademark registration.
 

Full vs Partial Cancellation

A registered trademark is immune from cancellation based on non-use for three years following its registration. After this time, the mark becomes potentially vulnerable to cancellation if it is not used in Korea. 
 
Cancellation actions are typically initiated to overcome an obstacle to registration when clearing a new trademark, and may be filed pre-emptively following a clearance search or after an office action cites the senior mark as an obstacle to registration. In either case, you may choose to target specific goods or services in a partial action, or seek cancellation of the entire registration in a full cancellation action.
 
The similarity code system provides a useful starting point in ascertaining which goods or services formally conflict between applications. If a senior application covers a broad range of goods or services spanning many similarity codes, the safest option is normally to target only those under the similarity code(s) that pose an obstacle, either together or in separate actions. The reason for doing so is simple: a trademark owner may defeat a cancellation action by providing suitable evidence of use for any one goods item or service included in the cancellation request. There is no obligation to provide evidence of use for all the targeted goods and services. Thus, there is often little benefit in expanding the scope of a cancellation action beyond what is strictly necessary, as this only serves to provide the trademark owner with more opportunity to defeat it.
 
This leads to some strategic planning being necessary when considering a cancellation action based on non-use. As an example, consider an applicant that wants to file a new application covering goods that fall under similarity codes A and B. From a search they discover a similar senior mark on the register that already covers goods under similarity codes A and B, in addition to unrelated goods under code C. Based on their market research, it seems the senior trademark owner is possibly using the mark at least for the code A and C goods. In this situation the following scenarios are possible:
 
(1) Full cancellation action (targeting all goods covered by senior registration) 
   → Trademark owner provides evidence of use only for code C goods
   → Action is entirely defeated and registration is unaffected
 
(2) Partial cancellation action targeting only code A and B goods of interest
   → Trademark owner provides evidence of use only for code A goods
   → Action is entirely defeated and registration is unaffected
 
(3) Separate partial cancellation actions targeting code A goods (1st action) and code B goods (2nd action)
   → Trademark owner can only provide evidence of use for code A goods
   → 1st action is defeated (code A goods remain registered), but 2nd action succeeds (code B goods are cancelled)
 
To avoid pitfalls such as the above, it is strongly recommended to discuss the filing strategy in detail with Korean counsel before proceeding with cancellation actions. 
 

What Counts as Acceptable Use

When defending a non-use cancellation action, the trademark owner must submit evidence of genuine use of the trademark with respect to at least one of the goods or services included in the cancellation request, or provide a justifiable reason for non-use. Qualifying use should have been made during the three-year period preceding the filing date of the action.
 
The mark: Exact use of the trademark in its registered form is safest, but limited variations in color, typeface, etc. may qualify if consumers would regard the form used as commercially identical. Material changes may not preserve the registration and can create misleading-use risk.
 
The user: Qualifying use must generally be attributable to the registered trademark owner or their exclusive/non-exclusive licensee. If used by a licensee but the license arrangement is not already recorded in the trademark register beforehand, the relationship must be objectively proven during the proceedings.
 
The use: Ordinary commercial acts such as placing the mark on goods or packaging; selling, delivering, displaying, exporting or importing marked goods; and using the mark in advertising or transaction documents are all acceptable. The evidence must show use as a trademark for the relevant goods or services. While a large volume of sales is unnecessary, token transactions engineered only to defeat cancellation may be rejected. Use commenced only after the cancellation petition is filed cannot cure the preceding three-year period of non-use.
 
The evidence: To avoid challenges, the best evidence links the mark, goods, date, Korean destination and authorized user across several records. Useful evidence will often include invoices, purchase orders, customs and shipping documents, dated product and packaging images, catalogues, Korean advertising, e-commerce records and archived webpages. 
 
Evidence of actual sales and supply is the strongest form of evidence, with other documents showing advertising, promotion or online exposure useful as supporting evidence provided their publication date can be verified. For online evidence, the posting date is key and Wayback Machine caches can be useful where available.
 
Justifiable non-use: The owner must show an external obstacle outside of their control, not simply a poor commercial climate. Natural disasters and legal or regulatory restrictions may qualify, while lack of demand, internal restructuring or a voluntary pause in sales will not. 
 

Practical Takeaways

For brand owners, best practice is to maintain clear use evidence records as part of ordinary portfolio management. To the extent possible, sales invoices, purchase orders, shipping records, dated product and packaging images, advertising materials and archived webpages should be collected periodically and organized by mark, designated goods and date. Where a Korean distributor or licensee uses the mark, the agreement should require it to preserve and regularly provide its own sales and promotional materials. A license agreement alone will not prove actual use.
 
Before attacking a third-party registration, it is equally important to define the objective carefully. Preliminary investigations should assess whether the mark is genuinely unused and identify the particular goods or services obstructing the intended application. In many cases, narrowly targeted or separate partial cancellation actions will be safer than challenging a broad group of goods together, since evidence of use for just one targeted item may defeat the entire action. 
 
A successful cancellation action does not transfer the mark to the petitioner or give the petitioner an exclusive right to register it, so the cancellation strategy should also be coordinated with the applicant’s own Korean filing strategy and, where the problematic registration was defective from the outset, consideration should be given to whether invalidation is the more appropriate route.
 
2026-10-15 08:42:00